Archibald Scott Couper

Archibald Scott Couper (March 31, 1831, Kirkintilloch, East Dunbartonshire, Scotland&mdash;March 11, 1892, Kirkintilloch) developed the theory of chemical structure, namely that tetravalent carbon atoms can link together to form large molecules, and that the bonding order of the atoms can be determined from chemical evidence. He published this theory in his paper "On a New Chemical Theory", Philosophical Magazine 16, 104-116 (1858) (excerpted in Alembic Club Reprint #21, On a New Chemical Theory and Researches on Salicylic Acid).

The only surviving son of a wealthy textile mill owner near Glasgow, Couper studied at the universities of Glasgow and Edinburgh and intermittently in Germany during the years 1851-54. He began the formal study of chemistry at the University of Berlin in the fall of 1854, then in 1856 entered Charles Adolphe Wurtz's private laboratory at the Faculty of Medicine in Paris (now the University of Paris V: René Descartes). He published his "New Chemical Theory" in French in a condensed form on 14 June 1858, then in detailed papers simlutaneously in French and English in August 1858. Couper's idea that carbon atoms can link to each other following valence regularities was independent of a paper by August Kekulé proposing the same concept (Kekulé had already proposed the tetravalence of carbon in 1857). However, through a misunderstanding with Wurtz, Kekulé's paper appeared in print first (in May 1858), and so Kekulé captured the priority for the discovery of the self-linking of carbon atoms. When Couper angrily confronted Wurtz, Wurtz expelled him from the laboratory. In December 1858 Couper received an offer of an assistantship from the University of Edinburgh.

But Couper's health began declining after this disappointment. In May 1859 he suffered a nervous breakdown, and entered an institution as a private patient. Released in July 1859, he almost immediately suffered a relapse -- it was said to have been from sunstroke -- and was treated again until November 1862. But his health was now broken, and he did no more serious work, spending the last 30 years of his life in the care of his mother.

Couper's research differed from Kekulé's in certain ways. He was open to the idea of divalent carbon, which Kekulé was not. He provided many more resolved formulas in his paper than Kekulé had, and in two cases even suggested (hetero)cyclical formulas (which could have been influential on Kekulé in his later suggestion of the benzene ring). He adopted the atomic weight of oxygen as 8 rather than 16, so there are twice as many oxygen atoms in Couper's formulas as in those of Kekulé. Finally, he provided dotted lines or dashes between the atoms in his formulas, approximating the appearance of later formula styles. In this respect, his work was probably influential on the early structural theorists Aleksandr Mikhailovich Butlerov and Alexander Crum Brown.